Qualitative Methods

Reflexivity in qualitative research

Reflexivity is the ongoing, critical examination of how you, the researcher, shape your study: the questions you ask, the data you collect, and the meaning you take from it. In qualitative research you are the main instrument, so instead of trying to remove yourself, you make your influence visible. In practice that means keeping a reflexive journal during the study and writing a positionality statement that tells readers who you are in relation to the topic and participants.

Get the free Qualitative Coding Worksheet Pack

One email with your download, then occasional research tips. One-click unsubscribe, anytime. We never sell your data.

The short answer

In a survey or an experiment, you try to keep the researcher out of the result through standard procedures. In interviews, focus groups, ethnography or document analysis, that is not possible. You decide what to ask, which follow-up questions to pursue, what counts as a code, and which pattern becomes a theme. Two careful researchers could produce different but defensible analyses of the same transcripts.

Reflexivity is how you deal with that honestly. You ask, at every stage, “How am I shaping this?” and you record the answers. Finlay (2002) describes reflexivity as moving beyond simple self-awareness to a critical look at how the researcher and the research process interact. It is also one of the practices most often linked to the confirmability and credibility criteria of trustworthiness proposed by Lincoln and Guba (1985). The trustworthiness guide explains those criteria in full.

Two outputs make reflexivity visible to examiners: a reflexive journal kept while you work, and a positionality statement in the thesis itself.

Types of reflexivity

Authors slice reflexivity in different ways, and no single list is official. Finlay (2002) maps several variants of reflexive practice, including introspection, intersubjective reflection and social critique. For a thesis, the three-part distinction below is common and easy to apply.

TypeThe question you askExample prompt for your journal
Personal reflexivityHow do my experiences, values and identities shape what I notice and how I interpret it?Which parts of this interview felt familiar from my own life, and did I probe them less?
Epistemological reflexivityHow do my assumptions about knowledge, and my design choices, shape what this study can find?Would a different question or method have produced different kinds of answers?
Relational (interpersonal) reflexivityHow does my relationship with participants, including power and status, shape what they tell me?Did my role or title make it harder for this participant to criticize their workplace?

You do not need to label every journal entry by type. The types are prompts that stop you from reflecting only on your feelings and forgetting your design and your relationships.

Keeping a reflexive journal

A reflexive journal is a dated, private record of your thinking across the study. Lincoln and Guba (1985) recommended a reflexive journal as one technique supporting trustworthiness. It is raw material, not a chapter, so write freely and briefly.

  1. Start before fieldwork. Write down why you chose the topic, what you expect to find, and what you hope to find. These early expectations are the ones that most need watching.
  2. Write after every data collection episode. Within a day of each interview or observation, note your reactions, what surprised you, what you avoided asking, and how the participant seemed to see you.
  3. Record decisions and reasons. Changes to the interview guide, sampling, codes or themes all go in with the reason at the time. This doubles as an audit trail.
  4. Keep writing during analysis. Note where a theme came from, which interpretation you favored and why, and what evidence would have pointed the other way.
  5. Review it at intervals. Reread earlier entries before each analysis phase. Look for assumptions you have stopped noticing.
  6. Use it in the write-up. Draw on specific entries for your positionality statement, methods chapter and limitations. You rarely quote the journal at length, but it lets you write concretely.

Check with your ethics committee and supervisor how to store the journal, because it may contain details about participants. Treat it with the same confidentiality as your transcripts.

Writing a positionality statement

A positionality statement is a short passage, usually in the methodology chapter, that sets out who you are in relation to the study and what you did about it. A useful structure:

  1. Relevant background. Only the parts of your identity and experience that bear on this topic and these participants. This is not an autobiography.
  2. Insider, outsider or both. Say how close you are to the participants’ world, and in what ways you are not.
  3. Assumptions you brought in. Name the expectations you held at the start.
  4. Likely influence, both ways. How your position may have helped (access, rapport, understanding of jargon) and how it may have limited the study (taken-for-granted meanings, participants holding back).
  5. What you did about it. The concrete steps you took: journal, debriefing, checking interpretations, seeking disconfirming cases.

Write it in the first person. Most qualitative traditions accept “I” in this section, but check your department’s conventions.

Worked example: a nurse interviewing nurses

Suppose you are a registered nurse doing a master’s in nursing. Your study explores how newly qualified nurses in hospital wards experience their first year of night shifts. You plan semi-structured interviews and reflexive thematic analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006, 2019). This example shows the process only; there are no data or findings.

Draft positionality statement. I am a registered nurse with several years of ward experience, including night shifts during my own first year of practice. I am now a part-time student and do not hold a management role over any participant. My position is partly that of an insider: I share participants’ professional language and know the routines of night work, which helped me build rapport and follow up on clinical detail. I am also an outsider in some respects, because I trained at a different time and in a different hospital, and I am now further from the ward than the people I interviewed.

I began the study expecting that night shifts would be described mainly as isolating, because that was my own experience. To keep this expectation from steering the interviews, I wrote it down before fieldwork, used open questions that did not assume difficulty, and after each interview noted in my reflexive journal where I had followed up on stories that matched my own. During analysis I discussed early codes with my supervisor, who does not have a nursing background, and actively looked for accounts that did not fit the themes I was developing.

Notice what the statement does. It names a specific assumption, explains how the insider position cuts both ways, and lists actions. It does not claim that these steps removed the researcher’s influence, because in reflexive thematic analysis that influence is part of how themes are produced (Braun & Clarke, 2019).

Matching journal entries might look like this, written in note form:

Weak vs strong reflexive writing

WeakWhy it failsStronger
I bracketed my biases so they did not affect the findings.Claims neutrality that interpretive research cannot deliver, and gives no detail.I recorded my expectation that night shifts would feel isolating before fieldwork and checked my follow-up questions against it after each interview.
As a nurse, I am an insider.States a label without saying what it changed.Sharing participants’ clinical language helped rapport, but I may have taken some routines for granted, so I asked participants to explain terms in their own words.
A page on my childhood, career and personal values.Self-disclosure that is not tied to the study.Two or three experiences that bear directly on the topic, each linked to a specific methodological step.
Reflexivity was maintained throughout.An assertion with no method behind it.I kept a dated reflexive journal from planning to write-up and drew on it when making and reporting analytic decisions.

Where reflexivity goes in your thesis

Some theses also include a short reflexive passage in the conclusion about how the researcher’s thinking changed. Ask your supervisor whether your field expects this.

Common mistakes

Checklist

If you want a simple place to log methodological choices as you make them, the free Research Decision Journal records each decision and prompts you to review it later, which pairs well with a reflexive journal.

Get the free Qualitative Coding Worksheet Pack

A first-cycle to second-cycle coding workflow with worksheets, an analytic memo log, and a saturation tracker. We’ll email you the download link.

One email with your download, then occasional research tips. One-click unsubscribe, anytime. We never sell your data.

Frequently asked questions

What is reflexivity in qualitative research?

Reflexivity is the researcher’s ongoing, critical attention to how their background, assumptions, relationships and choices shape the research process and findings. Rather than claiming neutrality, the researcher makes this influence visible so readers can judge the work.

What is the difference between reflexivity and positionality?

Positionality describes where you stand: your identities, experiences and relationship to the topic and participants. Reflexivity is the active process of examining how that position, and your decisions, affect the study at every stage. A positionality statement is one product of reflexive work.

What should a positionality statement include?

State your relevant background and identities, your relationship to the topic and participants (insider, outsider or both), the assumptions you brought in, how these might have helped or limited the study, and what you did about them during data collection and analysis.

How do you write a reflexive journal?

Write short dated entries throughout the study: before fieldwork, after each interview or observation, and during analysis. Record your reactions, assumptions, surprises, decisions and the reasons for them. Then draw on the journal when you write your methods and discussion.

What are the types of reflexivity?

Common distinctions include personal reflexivity (how your own experiences and values shape the work), epistemological reflexivity (how your assumptions about knowledge and your design shape what can be found) and relational or interpersonal reflexivity (how the relationship with participants shapes the data). Finlay (2002) describes several variants of reflexive practice.

Is reflexivity required in thematic analysis?

In reflexive thematic analysis, as described by Braun and Clarke, the researcher’s active, interpretive role is central, so reflexivity is part of the method rather than an optional extra. Other qualitative approaches also expect it, though the depth required varies by field and journal.

Is reflexivity the same as bias?

No. Bias implies an error to be removed. Reflexivity accepts that a researcher’s perspective will shape interpretive research and asks you to examine and report that influence openly, so readers can judge how it affected the findings.

The workbook for this

The Qualitative Coding Workbook

Are you staring at hundreds of pages of interview transcripts, wondering how to turn raw words into defensible findings? You are not alone.

45 fill-in templates. Paperback $35.99 on Amazon

See inside the workbook

Just want the templates? The Qualitative Coding Kit: every template as a fillable PDF, $19. Or all 17 kits for $99.

← Qualitative methods guide Open the Research Decision Journal →